CHRISTIANITY AND REALISMBy
Eric D. Butler
This was the Christmas message Eric D. Butler sent to his
readers in 1940 during the dark hours of national peril. It
is just as relevant today - if not more so - than it was 66 years ago!
"And
numerous, indeed, are the hearts to which Christmas brings a brief season of happiness
and enjoyment. How many families, whose members have been dispersed and scattered
far and wide in the restless struggles of life, are then re-united and meet once
again in that happy state of companionship and mutual goodwill which is a source
of such pure and unalloyed delight, and one so incompatible with the cares and
sorrows of the world that the religious belief of the most civilised nations,
and the rude traditions of the roughest savages, alike, number it among the first
joys of a future condition of existence, provided for by the blest and happy!
How many old recollections, and how many dormant sympathies, does Christmas time
awaken!" -Charles Dickens, in "The Pickwick Papers." I
think that, under normal conditions, the sentiments expressed in the above lines
of Charles Dickens would always strike a sympathetic chord in the hearts of the
majority of people. Although there will be many hundreds of thousands of homes
which will not know even the usual joys of Christmas this year - it is impossible
for the tens of thousands of the men on active service to be re-united with their
families - there is no reason why those of us at home should not take a brief
respite from our labours and calmly review the struggle we are engaged in. There
is no reason why we should not see the whole nation united in a determined resolve
to really win this struggle for ourselves. Future Christmases will then become
the festive season which Dickens spoke about-in fact, the philosophy of Christ
will prevail at all times. CHRISTIANITY
AND REALISM. Some people imagine that Christianity has very little to do
with realism; that it has to do only with abstract ideals. Of course, when we
think about Christmas we think about Christ. Did He not say: "Faith without
works is dead"? A careful study of the New Testament reveals Christ as a
great realist. It is very hard to be a realist at times. We prefer to think of
things as we would like them to be, instead of facing them as they are. For
example, it appears quite futile to me to be discussing whether we should be at
war or not. We are at war, and all the wishful thinking which some people indulge
in is no real contribution to the problem of emerging from the war with our political
and other institutions still intact. Some people in this country get into a frenzy
of emotionalism because of the tremendous hammering that Britain is getting from
the air. Those who are facing the position
with the greatest realism are those who are being hammered. We must expect these
things; we can expect worse things. "The wages of sin is death"; we
have sinned - not in the moral sense - we have failed to accept our responsibilities
in the past. That failure has resulted in the present world cataclysm. The
financiers and their satellites expect others to face their responsibilities while
they look after themselves. I can't say that I have much time for that type of
person. We have Mr. Noel Coward out here at
the moment putting over ideas, which sound suspiciously like Federal Union - -
he talks a lot about his American friends and "Dick Casey." Mr.
Coward may be sincere, but can he help us to face our responsibilities in this
country? He admits that he didn't face his own while in Britain - i.e., "I
took very little interest in politics until lately." It is because of people
like Mr. Coward that Britain is in her present plight. I would suggest to Mr.
Coward that, if he really is a part of British society in the organic sense, his
place is in Britain, endeavouring, with his fellow citizens, to force British
policy in the right direction - a policy of victory for the British people, and
not a victory for private financial institutions. ORGANISED
CHURCHIANITY It will be appropriate in these reflections on Christmas if
we briefly examine the fundamental ideas of the great teacher whose birth gave
rise to the festive Christmas season. Apart from being a realist, he was also
an individualist; he believed in the sanctity of the individual -i.e.: "The
Kingdom of God is within ye." He attacked the insidious doctrine of "leadership"
as we see it flourishing on all sides to day. His most important teaching was
that institutions existed only for the purpose of serving the individual. I am
quite convinced that the Man who opposed usury and whipped the money-changers
out of the temple would be horrified to see today certain aspects of what I can
only term "organised churchianity." Usury
is not only condoned; most churches are in debt to the modern money-changers and
collect tribute from the people on behalf of the usurers. Christ's views on "organised
religion" challenge those who have, on the whole, opposed his philosophy
- i.e., the Jews.
For this reason the following extracts from the "Jewish
Encyclopedia" are most interesting:- "It is difficult to decide
the question whether Jesus contemplated a permanent organisation to carry out
His ideas. The whole tendency of His work
was against the very idea of organisation . . . and His evident belief in an almost
immediate reconstruction of the whole social and religious order would tend to
prevent any formal arrangements for a new religious organisation... The opposition
between His followers and the 'world' or settled and organised conditions of society
would also seem to imply that those who were to work in His spirit could not make
another world of their own with the same tendency to conventionality and spiritual
red tape. On the whole it may be said that He did not make general plans, but
dealt with each spiritual problem as it arose... He was content to let the
influence of His own character work upon the persons immediately surrounding Him,
and that they should transmit His influence silently and without organisation,
working by way of leaven, as His parable puts it."
The underlying implications of the above extracts are worthy of close study by
all Christians. THE GROWTH OF POLITICAL
CHRISTIANITY I have referred in these columns
in the past to the contribution of the Anglo-Saxon race to civilisation. Apart
from the fundamental genius of this race - contributed to by the invasion of the
Norsemen with their spirit of adventure and inquiry, and the Norman invasion with
an introduction of the fine aristocratic outlook - the real philosophy of Christianity
was readily accepted and has progressively become the policy of the nation.
I am indebted to Norman F. Webb, an English writer, for the following extracts
from his "European Background": "The
truth is essentially not a matter of dogma, but of demonstration. As with individuals,
so with nations. The national culture which produces the greatest degree of individual
freedom, mental and material, is the Christian community
" "Christianity
had come to Britain in the 7th century, (it is now thought Christianity came to
Britain much earlier than the 7th century...ed) and there its establishment and
growth was the establishment and growth of the nation . . .. When, therefore,
Britain emerged from the condition of contending Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, it was
a peculiarly homogeneous Christian nation . "...
It was that their political structure was more directly influenced by the Christian
ideal of individual freedom and responsibility. It was due to this fact, seconded
by the accident of racial mixture, and climate, and geographical position, that
the Anglo-Saxon Englishmen developed a feeling for independent and voluntary co-operation;
for resourcefulness without guile, and competition without malice-in other words,
the sporting instinct - that showed conspicuously in later medieval Europe, and
by contrast, with added brightness against the blackness of the bigotry of the
Counter-Reformation. This it was that constituted the working Christian model
- quite outside and beyond all disputes of Churches, or sects, or dogma - of the
post-Renaissance world." POLITICAL
CHRISTIANITY Political Christianity - the representative system of government
- slowly developed in England. It has slowly spread in many parts of the world.
The British Commonwealth of Nations owes its development and existence to political
Christianity. Unfortunately, economic Christianity
has not yet become a reality. Apart from the military struggle, which has left
thousands of families homeless in Britain, the economic struggle has deprived
thousands of families in this country of the means to enter into the spirit of
Christmas. In last Saturday's Melbourne "Herald" appeared an appeal
by the Trades Hall Council and the Central Unemployed Council for work for the
jobless. These "jobless" and their dependents will not know the joys
of Christmas. Many more instances would be given. Poverty and misery exist on
all sides
But, let us be of good hope. There
is reason to believe that the first streaks of light are visible in the dawn of
economic Christianity. Each and every one of us might stop and think for a few
minutes during the coming Christmas season; let us make a firm resolve that we
will see this struggle through; that we will shoulder our responsibilities as
realists. If we give ourselves to this greatest work with clarity of purpose,
we will at last see that those families "whose members have been dispersed
and scattered far and wide, in the restless struggles of life, are then re-united,
and meet once again in that happy state of companionship and mutual goodwill .
. .." Dickens's sentiments will be transformed into a reality.
New
Times 20 December 1940 |